"As writers, we have blinders on when it comes to our work-in-progress, and being able to get a fresh perspective can help catch flaws we wouldn't have been able to see."

It can be a bittersweet moment to curate your first lineup of beta readers! On one hand, you are excited to see how a reader responds to your story, and on the other nail-bitten hand, you're putting yourself in a vulnerable situation that invites criticism.

Betas are an incredibly valuable asset in story development. As writers, we have blinders on when it comes to our work-in-progress, and being able to get a fresh perspective can help catch flaws we wouldn't have been able to see.

I like to set up beta readers in waves so it's easier to manage. After each wave, I can revise based on the feedback and test to see if those revisions hit home in the second wave (and so on). Only start with 1-2 readers, as they will point out the obvious areas for you to fix before more eyes see it. Remember that every ounce of feedback and critique will evolve your story and prepare it for release. It's important to create a safe space for your beta readers where they are comfortable being totally honest.

Questions to ask beta readers:

• How did the opening line make you feel?
• What do you like and dislike about this character so far?
• What do you like and dislike about the world so far?
• In your opinion, what could make this chapter stronger?
• How would you describe the tone of this chapter?
• What needs more clarification?
• What felt like an info-dump?
• What do you think will happen next?
• Which character do you relate to most?
• On a scale of 1-10, how engaged were you during this chapter?
• How did you feel about the end of the chapter?
• What details made you laugh or smile?
• Did you feel transported into the scenes? Why or why not?

Frequently Asked Questions About Beta Readers

Should you pay your beta reader?

There are paid beta readers who do this professionally, and there are volunteer-based beta readers. On Storyfolk beta readers should all be voluntary and payment should never be requested after you have handed your manuscript over. Paid readers can be found on sites like Fiverr.

How do you reduce risk while working with beta readers?

• Do not share your full manuscript right away. Start with a chapter critique to see if they are a good fit and their responses are human-written.
• Be upfront about your expectations at the start (Do not share, do not use AI…etc).
• You can have them sign an NDA.
• Tag your manuscript.
• If you are working with a paid beta reader, check their reviews, profiles, and social media. - See if they appear to be using AI to write/create their bio, service descriptions, or posts.
• If you are under 18 please ask a parent or guardian to connect with beta readers on your behalf.

How can I thank my volunteers?

• Send them a copy of your book when you publish.
• Thank your beta and ARC readers on your acknowledgments page.

What if I don’t agree with the feedback?

This is normal as art is suggestive and you will get all sorts of feedback. The first thing to do is remember that everyone has different preferences and you should take criticism with a grain of salt, the second thing is to determine if the feedback fits a pattern, or if others have said the same thing. If multiple readers are telling you something specific should change, give it a try and see if the story benefits.

Always thank your readers for being open and honest with their feedback. Avoid arguing or defending your choices. If something doesn’t land or they miss context, that’s the nature of reading.